Goudy Medieval, the old font

Goudy Medieval is a blackletter font that has been used on some older Magic the Gathering cards, primarily on the card name and type lines. This font, designed by Frederic Goudy in 1928, features ornate and elaborate letterforms with sharp points and angles, giving the cards a distinctive medieval look.

As Mark Rosewater wrote on an article in 2003:

"It was selected because it had a very fantasy feel to it. Unfortunately, it’s a hard font to read from a distance. In addition, whenever we had to use lower case letters, they bumped into the bevel above the art box. The font for the rules text, incidentally, has not changed on the new cards."

You can get it here